← Back to Index

‘Way of MA’ – System Philosophy

A living overview of a developing philosophical framework: thought, lens, system, metaphysics, and ethics.

I. Introduction

In the following we shall present an overview of a work in development, namely a comprehensive, overarching philosophical endeavour of the “Way of MA” project.

Despite the similarities, it should not be understood as a closed, sealed and static system, but as an open, breathing and living philosophical endeavour which bears resemblances to classical systems. The idea behind this project is not to arrive at the one and only view of reality, but to illustrate a possible perspective within which reality and experience can unfold. Thus, it is less about answers than about proposals and ideas, maybe even questions and prompts for one to continue working with.

The structure is such that we first explain what is meant by a “system”, and then go into an attempt at establishing one possible of such systems, before concluding with some comments and discussion.

II. Meta: Thought → Lens → System

Layer 1

Thought

After the senses relay information to the mind and experience is constructed, thought begins in its most primitive and raw form.

Example: A tiger sleeping underneath a tree is seen, but it is not yet labelled or declared to be a “tiger”, “tree”, etc. It just “is”.

Layer 2

Lens

Whatever we see when we think and experience in thought, is interpreted and mediated by a lens. This explains why some people see different things in the same information.

Examples:
Classical Western lens: stability, essence, binary truth.
Way of MA lens: tension, groundlessness, relational truth.

Layer 3

System

Once we have identified things within experience and begun to label them, bring them into relations and construct propositions around them, entities and axioms emerge.

Example: Entities: conflict, substance, time. Axioms: “Time is monodirectional.”, “Conflict is pervasive.”

One observation is therefore that thought leads to a lens which leads to a system, which in turn modifies thought and the lens in a cyclical manner.

Another observation is that because every system emerges from a lens, axioms within the system may feel self-evident to some people but not to others. This puts into question whether we can ever arrive at certainty in which axioms are evident and true, or whether each lens brings forth good arguments for their axioms. It might therefore be that axioms cannot be proven one way or another from within a system, but require a cyclical going through different lenses and comparison across systems to find stable patterns that yield such features as usefulness, goodness or maybe even truth.

Thought→Lens→System↺Modified Thought / Lens

III.A. Entities

External Entities

Entity / ConceptDescription
MultiplicityThe way in which there is more than one thing in the world.
ConflictThe situation in which two things are incompatible with one another.
RelationThe way in which two or more things connect to one another.
DependenceThe way in which one thing is incomplete without another and affected by that.
TensionThe principle of an agitation within or between things, which causes change.
Imperfection / LackThe absence of fullness, completion and wholeness of things.
ProcessThe way in which something evolves and develops over time.
ResistanceThe energetic pushing back on something by something else.
ConstraintThe limitation or boundary of something around something else.
DifferenceThe way in which two or more things are not the same.
InteractionThe way in which things behave in correlated and connected ways, affecting one another.
IncongruenceThe way in which e.g. the inner and outer worlds are in mismatch and not congruent.
TimeThe dimension across which things change, develop, and behave.
AgentThat which does, behaves and decides.

Internal Entities

Entity / ConceptDescription
Suffering / HappinessThe states of a negative / positive mind, i.e. perceived as undesirable / desirable.
DesireThe force that pushes an agent towards behaviour and doing and is an interest, want or wish.
Interpretation / MediationThe way in which meaning is projected into things, based on certain beliefs, models, systems.
ExperienceThe content of that which fills the conscious mind.
ConceptThe idea or semantic, logical and phenomenal object about something in the mind.
IdeaThe result of thinking around concepts, forging beliefs, etc.
MotivationThe force which pushes an agent’s behaviour ultimately and directs the doing.

III.B. Axioms

The axioms below are not presented as final, absolute foundations, but as provisional propositions within this system. They organise the way this lens interprets reality, mind, and the formation of inner worlds.

1. Groundlessness

There may not be an ultimate, objective, absolute and knowable ground to knowledge etc.

2. Multiplicity

There exist multiple things in the world.

3. Change and Impermanence

Change is everywhere in the concrete world, and things tend to be impermanent.

4. Tension

Incongruence produces tension.

5. Movement

Tension generates movement of the mind.

6. Constraint

The outer world and the mind constrain what is possible to think, believe and do.

7. Mediation

The mind interprets reality in an indirect way.

8. Projection

The mind projects ideas into reality.

9. Concept Construction

Beliefs are composed of concepts which are generated by the mind upon having experiences.

10. Incompleteness

Incompleteness/Lack are driving forces towards completion.

11. Thought and Seeking

Thought isn’t only truth-seeking, but stability-seeking.

12. Stabilisation

Structures tend towards temporary stabilisation.

13. Extremes as Unstable

Extremes are unstable and will dissolve into motion between the extremes again.

14. Incongruence

The difference between the outer and inner worlds are called the incongruence of worlds.

15. Reconstruction

Inner worlds etc. undergo construction and dissolution.

16. Decision

When multiple options exist, the decision is that which collapses their multiplicity into a singularity and chooses.

III.C. Logic

The following chains describe some of the internal logic of the system: not merely which entities and axioms exist, but how they may lead into one another.

Ontological Chain
Multiplicity → Relation → Incongruence + Direction → Conflict → Tension → Movement → Change

Difference or incongruence alone is not yet conflict; conflict arises when incongruence is interpreted under a direction, preference, law, or tendency.

Epistemological Chain
Experience → Mediation → Projection → Concepts → Beliefs → System → Stability → Rigidity → Tension → Collapse → Reconstruction
Phenomenological Chain
Incongruence (Ideal × Lack) → Tension → Desire → Movement × Constraint → Suffering

Here, incongruence means the mismatch between an ideal or desired state and a lack.

IV. Ethics

Building on top of the system’s descriptive foundation is the ethics, which accompanies the metaphysics and epistemology and so on.

IDNameProposition
1Existence of GoodsThere may be multiple goods. (E.g., happiness, life, fulfilled desires, …)
2Existence of BadsThe opposites to the goods are the bads.
3IdealIn an ideal world, all goods must be maximised and all bads minimised.
4RealThe real world constrains what goods can be maximised and what bads minimised.
5DecreaseA bad should be decreased unless it increases another bad, either (a) beyond a certain threshold, (b) proportionally too much.
6ScaleBecause a good and its respective bad share one scale, the increase in good is the decrease in bad and vice versa.
7Suffering “is-ought”The incongruence between the world as it is and the world as it ought to be – according to desires – manifests as suffering.
8Ultimate SystemThere may not be one ultimate ethical system, but a multitude that adapts to variables and stabilises under constraints.

V. Conclusion

The above illustration surrounding systems and of one of such systems should help us in thinking critically about how our beliefs and inner worlds are structured and how we may improve on that. By illustrating the constructed nature of systems and the necessity for a lens, through which experience is interpreted, we hope to have shown that this system – as should all systems – is but one possible suggestion by which we can navigate the world and life.

Furthermore, as philosophy appears to be reflexive and the results determine the starting conditions of doing philosophy, the system above will undergo changes in time and develop further – maybe not towards truth, but maybe usefulness and/or stability.

Version

v0.1 is the default version. Select v0.2 to show the added entity “Dependence” and the new III.C. Logic section.